13.04.08 - Surprise: Antibiotics Are Allowed in Organic Apple and Pear Farming
Summary: It may shock you to discover that antibiotic use in organic apple and pear orchards is routine. In fact, tetracycline has been on the national list of synthetic production materials allowed in organic farming since the mid-’90s.


The Nation Organic Standards Board decided to stick with the plan to end the exemption that allows for the use of antibiotics in organic apple and pear orchards next year.

Jack Jones (who asked that his real name not be used) takes care of a small organic pear orchard for a farmer south of the San Francisco Bay Area. This spring, as the trees have begun to blossom, he’s been spraying them with a small amount of the antibiotic tetracycline to prevent a disease called fire blight. 

Last year, when the perfect storm of warm, wet air first brought the bacteria to the farm, he tried removing infected branches and getting rid of cover crops, which were providing nitrogen that fed the disease. But to no avail—the disease had established itself in the trunks.

“It just devastated the orchard. We lost 80 percent of our trees in one season,” he recalls.

About half of the remaining 90 trees were a variety called Warren, which is immune to fire blight. For the rest, he decided to spray the tetracycline as a preventative measure, and is replanting the rest of the orchard with other varieties that are resistant to the disease.

It may shock you to discover that antibiotic use in organic apple and pear orchards is routine. In fact, tetracycline has been on the national list of synthetic production materials allowed in organic farming since the mid-’90s. Even so, antibiotic use in fruit production has largely gone unnoticed by the public, until now. With more focus on the larger issue of antibiotics in animal production—which accounts for nearly 80 percent of the antibiotics sold every year in the U.S.—a growing number of consumer advocates are sounding the alarm.

The growth in public awareness coincides with internal debate about the future of antibiotic use in organic orchards. Ahead of The National Organic Standards Board (NOSB) (the decision-making body behind the federal organic standards) meeting this week in Portland, Oregon, where members will discuss just how much longer farmers like Jones can continue routine use of antibiotics like tetracycline or streptomycin to control fire blight, several issues remain unresolved.

Debate pits consumer watchdog groups against farmers

There is an antibiotic-free alternative to controlling fire blight, a German product called Blossom Protect, which has had promising results in field trials. This is the first season it will be available for widespread commercial use, but growers simply don’t know if it will be reliable enough to effectively control the bacteria.

In the meantime, advocacy groups such as the Consumers Union, the Center for Food Safety, and Food & Water Watch have petitioned the NOSB to preserve the current phase-out date of 2014 for the antibiotics. Growers and scientists are pushing for an extension, which would allow for the use of tetracycline and similar drugs to control fire blight until 2016. 

Organic fruit farmer and NOSB member Zea Sonnabend is not optimistic that farmers will have other viable options by 2014. “Nobody wants to [use antibiotics], but on the other hand, farmers have not had enough political clout to get research funded for alternatives until now,” she told TakePart.

Blossom Protect, which Sonnabend says has done well in university tests in California and Oregon, hasn’t proven very effective in Michigan, a big apple-growing state. “If farmers only have one season [to test Blossom Protect], that’s not enough time for them to figure out all of the details—when to spray, how many times, how much to spray, etc. All that stuff takes experimentation on each farm.”

If the phase out happens before farmers feel confident, Sonnabend worries some will drop their organic certification to save their orchards.

“That will create a difficult choice for consumers because organic fruit can still be produced in areas where the fire blight disease hasn’t arrived yet, such as China, Argentina and Chile,” she adds.

These antibiotics were originally placed on the exception list with the understanding that they would be phased out eventually, but their exemption has been renewed several times since the federal standards went into effect in 2000. Consumer advocates say a 14-year exemption by the National Organic Standards Board allowing antibiotic use in organic apple and pear production provided more than enough time for growers to find alternative solutions to fire blight.

“I’m not saying this isn’t a difficult issue that farmers face, and it’s unfortunate that we’ve gotten to this point, but when is enough enough? At a certain point you have to call this use of antibiotics, which has gone on since 1995, into question,” says Lisa J. Bunin, Ph.D., Organic Policy Director for Center for Food Safety.

For those who say fighting fire blight is too difficult without the help of antibiotics, Bunin counters by pointing out that it’s already being done successfully by growers who export to Canada and the European Union, where such usage is prohibited.

“There are a large number of growers not using antibiotics because they want to sell to the EU market,” she says.

In Washington state, the nation’s leading producer of organic apples and pears, about 20 percent of orchards are antibiotic free, according to David Granatstein. A former organic farmer and head researcher at the Washington State University Tree Fruit Research and Extension Center, Granatstein has spent a great deal of his 25-year tenure studying the effects of fire blight on the industry there (he also keeps a detailed website where he collects data on the topic).

He says that even some of the farmers Bunin points to have had to give up their EU organic certification in bad fire blight years.

“For our growers to export to Europe, they have to prove they haven’t used antibiotics for three years. If they have a bad fire blight year and they have to use an antibiotic, they can still sell their products as certified organic in the U.S. If you’re on a site that doesn’t have a lot of fire blight, you can say, ‘what the heck’ and take that risk,” he says.

But if antibiotics are phased out before a viable alternative proves to be effective industry-wide, he says, those export growers will have to default to selling their fruit into the conventional market for three years. “The penalty would be much, much bigger,” says Granastein, who echoes Sonnabend’s concerns about the potential shrinking of the organic fruit industry, pointing to polling his center did with Washington farmers.

The research [PDF link] reads: 

Organic growers in Washington State were surveyed about their likely response to the loss of oxytetracycline in 2010 and 2011. Only 20-25% of the growers said such a loss would have little or no effect. When asked if they could effectively control fire blight in a year of high risk without antibiotics, 82% said no.

It turns out that some varieties are more resistant to fire blight than others. Unfortunately, those more at risk are the ones consumers know and love most—apples like Fuji, Gala, Golden Delicious, Pink Ladies and Granny Smiths. Pears that are most susceptible include favorites like D’Anjou, Bartlett, Bosc, and Comice. Will consumers be willing to switch to unfamiliar varieties like Winesaps or Melrose apples? It’s hard to say. But rather than take that risk, Granastein says some organic apple and pear growers have chosen to exit the organic market instead.

“One of the largest organic apple growers in Michigan has begun to transition out of organic because he doesn’t feel the tools are there,” he says.

Residue and resistance

Antibiotic residue on your fruit isn’t the foremost concern in this fight. While definitive information on how much of the drugs remain on fruit is still forthcoming, Granatstein has done some his own research. He and his researchers looked at fruit from trees that were sprayed with tetracycline during bloom time, or around 120 days before harvest.

“We’re not finding residues,” he says. “We haven’t published the data, but that’s what the initial results show. If you apply it 60 days before harvest you already have an apple that’s an inch and a half. There’s a surface to capture that spray. But the blossom captures it and falls off. This material, to my understanding, doesn’t move around in the plant, so it’s not going to be present in the developing fruit.”

What we do know is that fire blight has become resistant to streptomycin, which had been used in orchards since the 1950s. Consumer advocates are concerned that this will also happen with routine tetracycline use.

“To the degree that fire blight is becoming resistant to these antibiotics, it’s their own race to the bottom,” says Consumers Union’s Urvashi Rangan, director of consumer safety and sustainability.

What’s really at stake here, she says, is that allowing this fruit to carry the organic label is in fact compromising the term, and watering down the high standards that accompany it.

The lack of awareness and its impact on consumer expectation is what’s important to Rangan. An online survey of nearly 1,000 people conducted by The Consumer Reports National Research Center found that more than 80 percent of the respondents said they either didn’t think (68 percent) or didn’t know (17 percent) that antibiotics are used to treat disease in apple and pear trees. Once they were told, more than half of consumers said they don’t think the fruit should be labeled as organic.

“Consumers don’t know that antibiotics are being used in organic apple and pear production. At the very least, they should come up with a different label or disclose that use on the package. Call it ‘Organic-plus-Antibiotics’,” she says. “We think apple and pear growers who don’t use antibiotics should be able to differentiate their product, and right now, they can’t do that.”

Read Original Article.

Although we strive to provide you with relevant and reliable information on this news blog, the views and opinions expressed in the news stories posted on this blog do not necessarily reflect the opinion of Amazing Health or Amazing Discoveries. The AH News Blog is intended only as a service to provide you with interesting health-related news or to keep you abreast of events and attitudes of our current day. The postings are not intended to be an official statement or recommendation of Amazing Health or Amazing Discoveries. The reader should make his or her own judgment as to the usefulness of the information provided here.
Get Healthy!
Core Research
Healthy Living Resources
Health Hazards
Spirituality and Health
What's the right kind of Water for my Health?
Laws of health

Health is delicately balanced on eight health principles. Unfortunately, we have lived for so many years under unnatural conditions; we have gone so far away from the path of these health principles, that the very last thing we think of when seeking health, is the natural way.

We have been so deeply impressed with the false idea that we must have artificial aids, that most people have lost faith and confidence in purely natural methods. The times we live in are so artificially arranged that most of us lack confidence in the simple things and simple methods of healing.

Learn the eight laws of health that lead to an abundant life.
Air Sunlight Nutrition Water Exercise Rest Temperance Trust
Balanced Living
Dr. Rainda gives good advice on balanced living.
Herbs and Foods for Better Blood
Why is building your blood important? What does it mean to cleanse your blood? The answers to these questions could prove instrumental in guiding you to better health.
A Happy Family
Read about four important parenting tips from Ellen White to help develop a healthy family unit.
Moderate, monitored fasting can be part of a healthy detox regime.
The 21-Day Program Foods and Juices that Detoxify the Body Best Three-Day Water Fast Different Kinds of Fasting Why Fast? Fasting in the Bible
Getting a Good Start
Starting the day right involves a hearty, healthy breakfast.
Young Coconut Kefir
Learn what young coconut kefir is, in addition to all the wonderful benefits you will reap when consuming this ever so fabulous health tonic.
Stress, Stress, Go Away
Everyone experiences stress. We cannot heal from stress without understanding it first, and learning to deal with it head on.
How to Overcome Candida Naturally
What is Candida? Candida is the short name used to describe yeast overgrowth in the body. The technical term is Candidiasis. Like their &...
Acid-Base Balance in Food
How to Achieve a Perfect Combination
Diet-Induced Acidosis
Our bodies are in a state of constant motion. Even when we’re sleeping, the machinery of the body is at work.
Is Your Get Up and Go Gone?
Reprinted with permission from Lorna Vanderhaeghe Health Solutions, Inc. Visit www.hormonehelp.com for more information.
Charcoal Therapy
Every private home should have charcoal on hand as a ready antidote for poisoning, and as a cleansing agent in infectious and various metabolic disturbances.
Heart Health
A healthy heart is crucial for a healthy life. So why don't we take better care of our hearts?
Introduction to Heart Health Improving Your Blood Circulation Unclogging Your Arteries the Natural Way Oxygen for Life Pomegranate Health Power Solving the Varicose Problem
Use it or Lose it!
We keep our muscles strong and effective in the same way that we exercise our spiritual gifts and "prayer muscles" to keep them free from atrophy.
The Healing Power of Honey
From burns to weak bones, raw honey can help.
Fresh Vegetable & Fruit by Dr. N.W. Walker
Written in 1936 and still used as an essential reference today. Book Review.
Mighty Melons
Melons are more than just a sweet, juicy treat.
Iron in the Vegan Diet
Learn the importance of iron in the diet and how to get enough iron the vegetarian way.
Chia Seeds
Learn why you should make chia seeds a part of your diet.
Epsom Salt
Epsom salt, or magnesium sulfate, has long been used as a home remedy for a variety of ailments. Added to bath water, it has been used to relieve colds, back pain, ease muscle tension and treat certain skin conditions.
Epsom Salts in the Garden
Magnesium is a nutrient needed by plants for many growing processes.
A simple green algae food, chlorella, can help with dozens of health conditions.
Skin Care
Learn how to take care of your biggest organ: your skin.
The causes of Poor Skin Dry Skin Brushing and Washing Building Beautiful Skin Deathtraps in the Cosmetics we Use Supplements and Topical Treatments
Marvelous Magnesium for Your Heart
Every 7 minutes, someone in Canada dies of a heart attack or stroke. Cardiovascular disease is a leading cause of death and magnesium deficiency is a major contributing factor.
Some are suggesting that Americans must take immediate action to increase the magnesium in their diet. Is there really cause for alarm?
Soy Safety Summarized
Is soy a smart food to include in a healthy diet?
Scientists Discover That Plants Communicate via Symbiotic Root Fungi
Can plants really communicate? Ask Dr. Mercola.
The Gluten Connection: Weighing in Against Modern Wheat
Jean Handwerk explains the connection between modern wheat and many averse health effects.
Could Carrageenan be Harmful for your Body?
Carrageenan, a food additive made from seaweed, could be harmful.
Carob: Chocolate's Safe Alternative
Is chocolate really that bad? If so, what are the alternatives?
Find practical ideas for dealing with depression in these articles about symptoms and treatments.
Diseases of the Mind Ugly Words, Ugly Rice SAD and Bright Light Therapy
Dietary Patterns for Adults
It has been shown that a vegan diet can provide all the body’s needs and can be followed without fear.
Mammograms or Thermal Imaging?
Mammogram screening is becoming increasingly popular in North America. But is it the safest way to screen for breast cancer?
Different Diets for Different Blood Types?
Does Eat Right For Your Type by Dr. Peter J. D’Adamo align with Scripture and science?
Is Poor Digestion Poisoning You?
Even if you don’t feel sick, your digestion may be poor enough to slowly poison your system. No, this isn’t simply a theory, but the conclusion from years of laboratory testing and clinical experience. Autointoxication is real.
How to Kill a Cold, Starve a Fever
The fever is perhaps the most overtreated health symptom of all.
The Medical Properties of Clay
Tony de Morais explains the wide spectrum of uses for clay.
Many Doctors Ignore the Root Cause of Cancer
In 1971 President Nixon and Congress declared war on cancer. So what's happened in the 40 years since? After weeding out the hype and filling in the actual statistics, it turns out, not much.

An Ounce of Prevention
Can anything be done to prevent common illnesses?
Mercury Poisoning from Amalgam Dental Fillings
Don't let dentists put this poison in your mouth!
Potato Power
A look at the health benefits of potatoes.
Tylenol, the tip of the iceberg
Dr. Hugo Rodier explains the danger behind prescription drugs and painkillers.
Multiple Sclerosis
Dr. Roy Swank found that the diets of those with Multiple Sclerosis can make a difference in their prognosis.
Are Hospital Births or Home Births Safer?
Take a closer look at the safety of midwife-assisted home births versus hospital births.
Nature's Planting Table
Several charts show best time to plant vegetables in accordance with blooming time of perennials.
Garden Vegetable Planting Amounts Per Person
A helpful chart for those wanting to grow their own garden vegetables.
Rule of Thumb for Spacing in the Garden
Chart showing how to space your vegetables in the garden and how to care for your plants.
Heating with Wood
Why is wood heating such a good idea?
Back to the Garden
Steve Day explains the importance of nutrient-rich soil for growing produce.
Scientific Soil Feeding
Mineral deficiencies in soil, using a refractometer, and making the most of your garden are all discussed.
Healthy Snack Alternatives
When you open the fridge to grab a snack, consider simple, healthy alternatives to sugar-filled munchies and beverages.
Sources of Calcium - Chart
A quick reference list of healthful, dairy-free ways to get your calcium.
Links for Healthy from Inside Out featured products
Find information on the products that Jeanie Davis recommends in Healthy from Inside Out
How to Clean Vegetables and Fruit
Learn the best, natural mixture to use when cleaning fresh veggies and fruit.
Shopping Guide to Avoiding Organic Foods with Carrageenan
When shopping for groceries, check the labels for carrageenan, a thickening agent scientists are blaming for various gastrointestinal illnesses.
The Best Houseplants for Purifying the Air
The World Health Organization (WHO) recently released an air quality model to show that more than 9 in 10 people live in areas that have unsafe levels of air pollution.
What are the benefits of this so-called "weed"?
Animal Products and Food-borne Illness
Food borne illness is on the increase worldwide. In most cases, animal products are implicated as the main source of infection.
Schedule for a Healthy Lifestyle
Health is about more than just diet or exercise.
Healthy Meal Ideas
Inject some fun into your food routine with these healthy meal ideas.
Dirty Dozen List of Endocrine Disruptors
12 Hormone-Altering Chemicals and How to Avoid Them. Copyright © Environmental Working Group, www.ewg.org. Reprinted with permission.

Pain Management 101
Pain pills aren't always the best way to deal with aches and soreness. Various therapies—including vibrational therapy—can have you on the road to recovery.
Compatible Combinations of Plant Foods
Some fruits and vegetables should not be eaten together, as they can react and cause digestive issues.
Chocolate and Carob Compared
Have you considered carob as an alternative to chocolate? See for yourself the impact chocolate can have on your health.
Acid and Alkaline Ash Food Groups - Graph
Learn about the acidity or alkalinity of your favorite foods.
Damaged Minds
Excitotoxins cause physical and spiritual destruction.
Introduction to Excitotoxins What are Excitotoxins? Health Risks Diet Soda Meat Substitutes Aspartame
Top 10 Food Additives to Avoid
Food additives have been used for centuries to enhance the appearance and flavor of food and prolong shelf life. But do these food additives really “add” any value to your food?
Is consuming alcohol ever a good idea?
Is a Little Wine Good for the Heart? Is a Little Wine Good for the Soul? Intoxicants
Smoking leads to massive amounts of sickness and death every year.
Tobacco Kicking the Tobacco Habit Nicotine and Depression
Meat Mysteries
Maybe vegetarianism is the best option after all...
Poisoned Meats Clean and Unclean Mad Cow Disease Getting the Pork Out
The Dairy Controversy
Get the truth about lactose, calcium, and the need for caution around dairy products.
Drink Milk? Udder Propaganda Lactose Intolerance Why Women Crave Chocolate Why You Should Switch From Chocolate to Carob Osteoporosis Did You Say, "Pass the Milk?" Calcium
Genetically Modified Foods
The agriculture industry is fast becoming reliant on genetically modified foods. Learn the facts about GMOs and the effects this trend is having on health worldwide.
Introduction to Genetically Modified Foods Still Eating Genetically Modified Foods? The Big GMO Cover-up MSG: Is This Silent Killer Lurking in Your Kitchen Cabinets
Diabetes: An Epidemic Disease
Diabetes is spreading across North America. Is there anything we can do to stop this killer disease?
Sugar—Affecting the Body and Mind
Refined sugar is addictive, destructive, and devoid of any nutritional value. Why does it continue to be a staple food across the world?
Introduction to Sugar—Affecting the Body and Mind Sugar and Mental Illness Eating Sugar is Worse than Eating Nothing at All Sugar Substitutes The Truth About Evaporated Cane Juice Coke or Water?
The Additive Invasion
There are now over 3,000 additives in our foods. Incredibly, only 7% have any nutritional value.
Do the stimulating benefits of coffee really outweigh the costs?
America's Number One Drug Problem—Coffee Caffeine
Refined Grains
Most of the bread products consumed today are made of refined grains. Are our breakfast cereals and "fortified" loaves as healthy as we like to think?
Vaccination: A Medical Abomination
Vaccination began 200 years ago as an experimental life-saving medical tool. While it originally had some merit, today it has become perhaps the leading cause of death and disability among our children.
Introduction to Vaccination: A Medical Abomination Hepatitis B Vaccines Have You Had Your Flu Shot?
Music and the Frontal Lobe
Music enters the brain through its emotional regions, which include the temporal lobe and the limbic system.
Compromise in the Pharmaceutical Industry
Plant medicine safety pale in comparison to the promotional and safety practices of the mainstream drug industry.
Introduction to Evidence For Design
This article uses pieces of nature, such as the genome, the cell, and even the eye, as evidence that God is the Creator of all things.
A Good World Gone Bad
If God made the world, and our bodies, then the Creation story can give us clues about how we should live for optimum health. But how did what God called "good" transform into a dog-eat-dog world of carnivores, thorns, parasites, and other ugly aspects of Creation?
Rapid Transformation
Change over time seems to prove devolution rather than evolution. But what does rapid transformation show?
Evidence For Transformation
It seems clear that organisms change over time. But why? Is it evolution?
An Imperfect Planet
If God made everything so good, why are there so many problems? Are thorns and weeds evolved adaptations or changes in Creation?
The Dawn Chorus and Life Forces
Some call it cacophony and are driven to madness; others find it the most beautiful event in all of creation—the dawn chorus of the birds.
The Cell is Evidence for Design
The cell is an intricate factory full of well-oiled machines. Is it possible that the cell came about by chance?
The Organs are Evidence for Design
Human and animal organs sometimes seem to lend credence to the evolutionary theory. What's the truth?
The Genome is Evidence for Design
The complexity of microscopic genetic material points to Intelligent Design.
What Water Should I Drink?
There are many types of water available today. Some are better for your health than others.
Are You Drinking Enough Water?
Learn why drinking at least 2.5L of water per day is vital to your body's health at any age.
Why I Now Say No to Distilled Water Only
Day questions the benefits of drinking distilled water long-term.
Early Death Comes from Drinking Distilled Water
Dr. Rona writes about how drinking distilled water on a regular, daily basis is potentially dangerous.
Fluoride—Making us Stupid and Unhealthy
Fluoride in drinking water has been linked to decline in IQ and may cause health issues.
Signs You Need More Hydration
Dehydration is simply when your body does not have as much water and fluids as it should. Water makes up 60-80% of our entire body mass, so it makes sense that when we don’t consume enough, all kinds of issues start to occur! Consuming plenty of water each day is critical for your body to work at its best, so if you’re not getting enough, your body sends a whole range of signs that let you know you need to top up!
A Kidney Crisis
The following example of the kidneys explains one scenario of what could happen when your body goes into "crisis management mode" because it doesn’t have enough water.